
Profitability margins for coal generation rose to the highest against natural gas in over two years. The European coal market looks set to benefit from a short window of increased coal burn following sharp increases in natural gas pricing.
People participating in the market are pushing their forecasts up for coal use in 2025, thanks to rising clean dark spreads (CDS) in Germany. The margin for 40%-efficient coal plants has risen to a level we haven’t seen since January 2023: a CDS that holds a €31.652/MWh premium over the clean spark spreads (CSS) for 55%-efficient gas plants.
Germany’s coal margins stayed negative for almost all of 2024 but flipped to positive in October. Since then, the CDS premium over CSS has more than doubled, leading to a jovial outlook for coal burn, even under spread conditions that aren’t as favorable. Uniper’s Datteln 4 plant, one of Europe’s most efficient coal-fired power stations, was returned online in February. The average output from the restarted plant has pushed coal-fired generation in Germany to its highest level since November.
Natural gas prices in Europe hit a 25-month high on 10 February. On the other hand, coal has become relatively cheaper, with ARA hub coal prices falling nearly $9/t since the end of January. However, even with this steep decline in prices, any significant purchasing of coal doesn’t seem imminent, and the expectation is that coal will be burned in much higher quantities than in recent years. Why? Robust coal stocks at key hubs and a rising temperature in European power demand should offset any price increases coming from these hubs in the short term. These developments, especially concerning generation margins and fuel supplies, are influencing the immediate energy market in Europe.